Heart Shaped Strawberry Stuffed French Toast

HeartFrenchToast45French Toast was probably my favorite breakfast growing up and recently I’ve been receiving lots of different variations of this popular morning food.  Some with different fruits and spices, some stuffed, some layered, the classic single slice and family casserole style.  It made me wonder, why do we call it “French” toast anyway?  I know it’s not really French, or is it?

Wikipedia’s etymology says the earliest use of the term was in 1660 and was bread fried with wine, orange juice and sugar.  I’ll have to give that recipe a try!  After doing a little more digging through Google, I discovered in French it is actually called “pain perdu” which translates into “lost bread.”  It was a popular recipe in many countries, not just France, as a way of making stale bread palatable.  The English call it “gyspy bread” and I think I’d like to adopt that term from now on … sounds like breakfast with an adventurous edge!

While there are many different adaptations, the basics remain the same.  A simple batter of eggs and milk.  And I like to add a dash of vanilla, the way my Mom always made it.

This recipe comes from Diane Kenniston Hill Inn Bed & Breakfast in Maine. She likes to make her French Toast with shell or heart shaped homemade biscuits.  In lieu of biscuits I used some Texas sized bread.


Here’s what you’ll need:

The basics … milk, eggs, bread, butter

Add to that a dash of vanilla, some sugar, walnuts, strawberries, and maple syrup.


You can do this same recipe with whole slices of bread instead of heart shapes.  Or, if you’re like me, next time you walk through the baking section of your store and see all the cookie molds you’ll dream of French Toast in the shape of flowers, butterflies, kittens, birds, musical notes and the State of California.  (That last one was random, I know)

If’ you’re going to make it into a shape, cut your bread first …


Then add the milk, eggs, sugar and vanilla to a large bowl and mix well.


Pour mixed batter into a shallow bowl for dipping.


Then start layering into a 13×9 inch baking dish.


Slice your strawberries and layer on top of the bread.  Isn’t this starting to look like a lovely Valentine’s Day breakfast?



Next, put a layer of bread on top of the strawberries, sort of like a sandwich.


I poured the extra batter over top to fully soak them in eggy goodness.


Sprinkle with walnuts and add a dab of butter to the top of each toast.



Bake at 325 for about half an hour.


And you’ll have plenty of left over crust to make bread pudding … or feed the ducks.


When they’re finished, slice around the edge of the hearts with a knife and serve individually with strawberries and maple syrup.


Doesn’t it look like it’s sticking it’s tongue out?

That is, if French Toast could sass back and actually had a  tongue.


Mmm.  Delish.


Heart Shaped Strawberry Stuffed French Toast

12 slices of thick bread
1 cup milk
4 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 tablespoon sugar
1/2 cup chopped walnuts
1 cup sliced strawberries
pinch of salt
maple syrup

1) If using cookie cutter to make shapes, prepare and slice bread.
2) In a medium sized mixing bowl, whisk together eggs, milk, vanilla, sugar and salt.  Pour mixture into a shallow bowl for dipping bread.
3) Soak bread in egg mixture and add one layer into greased baking pan.
4) Cover first layer of bread with sliced strawberries.  Next, dip remaining bread in egg batter and add on top of strawberries like  a sandwich.
5) Sprinkle chopped walnuts on each piece and add a slice of butter.
6) Bake at 325 for 30 to 40 minutes.

About Rachelle Lucas

Rachelle is a writer, spokesperson, and travel videographer. She believes the best way to learn about a destination is through its flavors and collects recipes from her trips to recreate them here on The Travel Bite. She’s currently the Food and Dining Insider for Visit Florida and was recently named by KRED as one of the Top 50 Travel Bloggers in the world.

As much as Rachelle enjoys traveling and tasting new foods, she also loves to run. She’s completed the New York City Marathon and the Marine Corps Marathon as well at 5 half marathons.


  1. Great idea. As a florist, I have come to hate Valentine’s Day because it is usually so stressful and full of anything but love. But your recipe looks like so much fun I think I’ve (however briefly) remembered why Valentine’s Day has always been one of my favorite holidays. Valentine’s Day falls on a Sunday this year, so I’m going to make these with my kids for Sunday brunch. Thanks! Robin

  2. Robin … Omigosh. I worked at a florist when I was in college and Valentine’s Day was like the Super Bowl. Hopefully this breakfast will give you the energy you need for the day. :o)

  3. Beautiful presentation. What a pretty dish!

  4. I love the adorable heart shape of this dish! I’d love to try this with Challah bread. Now if only I can get my man to take a look at this recipe…

  5. Oh my goodness so cute! I’ll have to put this on my Valentine’s day menu for breakfast :)

  6. Cute shapes and look delicious, kids would love this.

  7. What a fun brunch dish for Valentine’s. It makes for a wonderful presentation.

  8. This looks like a very delicious recipe. We will be opening a B&B sometime this year in the Riding Mountain National Park area in Manitoba Canada. Hope you don’t mind if I use this recipe for perhaps one of our staples. This dish would be wonderful to offer a newly wed or anniversary couple as well. Thank you for sharing.


Speak Your Mind